Sparkle 1975 Vs. Sparkle 2012, Classy beats Assy!

1975I finally had a chance to watch Sparkle 2012 last night.  I did a brief tribute to Sparkle 1975 on February 12 this year after Whitney Houston passed on 2/11/12:

https://learnbellydancewithshalimarali.com/2012/02/12/singerdancer-tribute-21212-irene-cara-bronx-ny-what-is-your-favorite-scene-in-the-movie-sparkle-or-song-by-irene-cara/

Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE Whitney Houston!  And I LOVE that she made it possible to reboot Sparkle, one of my all-time favorite movies!

My sister hated the revised Sparkle movie.  And like many critics of the movie online, I can understand why.  The movie is a beloved African American classic.  And sometimes, it is best to leave classics alone.

Sparkle Cast 2012The movie ending was HORRIBLE!  I can see why my sister hated the movie so much.  I was watching from home, but the last 3 songs made me want to leave the theater, so to speak.  If I did watch it in a theatre, I may have left at One Wing.  R Kelly IS NOT Curtis Mayfield!  The final 3 songs by R Kelly completely ruined the ending.  It took the movie from being “Sparkle” to being an episode of any reality singing competition.  Take your pick, American Idol, The Voice, etc.  Even through Jordin Sparks may have been comfortable with the ending, as winner of American Idol.  Please, no music videos for the end of my beloved Sparkle.  Why, oh, why not just end it like the original with Sparkle singing Loving You Baby and Look Into Your Heart?

Sparkle Cast 1975Speaking of music soundtracks, allow me to go back into time to my 1975 bandwagon and complain about ARETHA FRANKLIN!  I LOVE Aretha, but why oh why did they let her sing the 1975 soundtrack songs INSTEAD of Irene Cara, Lonette McKee and Dwan Smith?  I had no choice but to buy it, since I loved the movie so much.  I could see why they chose Aretha over 3 “actresses” as she is a legend.  Very bad decision, as Irene, Lonette and Dwan KILLED those songs in the movie!

CASTING:  Tie for both movie versions.  Great casting for both!

MUSIC SOUNDTRACK:  The background music in the new Sparkle is the bomb!  What a great selection of oldies to listen to during the music.  The song focus in the 1975 version, were the actual songs while being performed, which made them stand out more than a “flood” of music.   But it did breathe a breath of fresh “old song” air into the new version.

Sparkle2012PLOT:  It was stupid to bring Sister back from the grave and waste her “life” with prison.  Mara had a chance to really, resurrect Sister.  Why not let her 3 years go by and let her perform the final number with Sparkle?  This was a wasted opportunity to have a group reunion with Delores?   I love the new empowerment having Emma own a dress store.  Not that there’s anything wrong with being a maid, like Effie in the 1975 version.  Why did they make Satin a comedian in the new version?  That was just dumb!  It would have been more realistic to make him a drug dealer.

SCRIPT:  The new script was awesome!  The dialogue was fresh.  Kudos to Mara Brock Akil and Salim Akil!

COSTUMES:  The 2012 costumes did not totally outshine the 1975 version.   I give a special kudos to the 1975 version released on DVD with the cool blue dresses on the cover that I did not see in the original film.

Sparkle1975DANCE CHOREOGRAPHY:  My brother is not a dancer, but he COMPLAINED about the dancing and costumes in the 2012 version.  The 1975 dance choreographies by Lester Wilson were sensuous and classy.  I usually LOVE choreographies by Fatima Robinson, but the 2012 dance choreographies tended to go overly sexy, trying to hard to look sexy, not appropriate for the 1960s, Raunchy, Lap Dance, Bump & Grind and Assy!  I am a Belly Dancer, so thought I would never say this about choreography, but the dances had too much BELLY DANCE!  Too many ummies, shimmies, undulations, etc.  Sort of LAZY choreography.  Please watch both versions of “Hooked on Your Love” to see what I mean.  Lonette McKee did not have to resort to a Lap Dance to kill that song.  Take notes  Carmen Ejogo!  The 1975 Sparkle had better costumes for Sparkle and Dee while performing that same song.  I can see why the 1975 Sparkle group won the contest against Doreen (Norma Miller); while the 2012 Sparkle group should NOT have won the contest, as the Girl Group before them (with Fatima Robinson and Goapele) should have won.  They were hands down way better than the Sister & Sisters!  I wanted to see more of them!!!

SPARKLE SHOWDOWN! 1975 VERSION 2012 VERSION Winner
Casting: 10 10
Music Soundtrack: 10 9
Plot: 8 9
Script: 8 9
Costumes: 9 9
Dance Choreography: 10 6
TOTAL 55 52 Sparkle 1975

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sparkle_%281976_film%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sparkle_%282012_film%29
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mara_Brock_Akil

WHICH DID IT BEST?
SPARKLE 1975
SPARKLE 2012

Coming soon:

The Vampire Dancer Saga Part 2!

Chapter 4:  Michael Jackson Dances back from the Grave!

http://www.amazon.com/The-Vampire-Dancer-Saga-Shalimar/dp/1477142177/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1344040118&sr=8-1&keywords=the+vampire+dancer+saga
The Vampire Dancer Saga back coverAMAZON KINDLE:
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B008P3089W
BARNES & NOBLE PAPERBACK:
http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/the-vampire-dancer-saga-shalimar-ali/1112297703?ean=9781477142172

TWITTER:
https://twitter.com/Shalimaral

FACEBOOK:
http://www.facebook.com/shalimar.ali.9

Advertisements

Comments are welcome/Spam is not/I like true comments/but bots do not!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s